Skip to main content

Phoenix Municipal Government Center Design Competition Collection

 Collection
Identifier: MS MSS 7

Scope and Content Note

This collection is divided into three Subgroups: 1) Planning Stage, 2) Design Competition Stage, including oversize design boards (Phase I and Phase II), and 3) Post-Competition Stage.

Subgroup 1 contains a single series, Reports. Included here are: the Proposed Competition Schedule of November 1984; Design Competition Procedures and Prospectus of February and March 1985; and news clippings from the Arizona Republic of April 1985.

Subgroup 2 contains six series. Series 1, Reports, consists of 17 folders and 2 volumes spanning from April 1985 to December 1986. These folders contain such documents as site development programs, building programs, final design proposals, master plans (some of which are oversize) and other design competition process documents submitted by architects who entered the competition.

Series 2, Jury Hearings, is comprised of seven folders containing transcripts of jury meetings and hearings from April, July, and October 1985. Series 3, Miscellany, includes clippings from the Arizona Republic and the New Times, as well as sketches and posters from the period. Series 4, Design Boards, consists of 25 oversize items housed in map case drawers that represent the works submitted for the competition by both semi-finalists and finalists. Series 5, Design Competition Videotapes, consists of 11 VHS cassette tapes that include formal presentations by the four finalists in the design competition. Series 6, Photos/Slides, is comprised of numerous color and black/white photographs of the finalist architects and their designs. A number of slides depicting models, perspective drawings, elevations, etc. are also present.

Subgroup 3 contains three series. Series 1, Reports, includes the post-1985 phase of the Phoenix Municipal Complex planning story in six folders. Folder titles include Book Publication on Design Competition, March 1986; Municipal Center Project Design Agreements, March, 1986; Costs of Alternative Scenarios, February, 1987; Capital Improvement Needs Study, November 1987; Analysis of Phoenix Downtown Development Project, October 1988; and Miscellaneous Documents, 1990. Within this latter folder is a noteworthy summary report on the design competition and Barton Myers' winning design compiled by Charles E. Hill, a donor of material to this collection.

Series 2, Miscellany, contains nine folders of correspondence (including letters of support for the municipal complex idea), clippings, publications, and sketches.

Series 3, UCLA/Wight Art Gallery Exhibit Videotapes, includes 23 3/4" tapes detailing the competition. The tapes were produced in conjunction with the touring exhibition of the U.S., titled Architecture of Democracy, that started at the University of California, Los Angeles in 1987.

Dates

  • Creation: 1984-1993

Language of Materials

Material in English

Access Restrictions

To view this collection, make an appointment at least five business days prior to your visit by contacting Ask an Archivist or calling (480) 965-4932. Appointments in the Design and the Arts Special Collections Reading Room at the Design and the Arts Library on the Tempe campus are available Monday to Friday from 10 a.m. to 4 p.m.

Historical Note

On April 12, 1985, the Phoenix City Council set the goal of a world-wide architectural design competition for a new municipal complex that would attract national and international attention by exhibiting a unique Phoenix Style. The plan proposed a complex that stretched from Central Avenue west to the State Capitol along Washington and Jefferson Streets. The complex was to include fire, criminal justice, and municipal buildings covering 214,000 square feet and costing $24,400,000.

Oregon architect Edward C. Wundram was commissioned to manage the competition, which was budgeted at $225,000. A jury of six local professionals and laymen as well as two outside professionals was appointed to select the winning entry. Over one hundred architects expressed interest and the jury named nine semi-finalists who submitted detailed plans. From these, the jury selected four finalists, one each from the United States, Canada, Japan, and Mexico.

Barton Myers of Toronto was ultimately selected as the winner of the competition in October 1985. In the months that followed the project became mired in controversies involving costs, practicality of design, and politics. By the summer of 1986 interest in continuing the project waned. In 1988 the city turned to the construction of a more modest twenty-story city hall at Third Avenue and Washington Street. This facility opened in November of 1993.

Full extent

8 Box(es)

Full extent

31 Oversize Folders

Full extent

10 Linear Feet

Abstract

This collection documents an architectural design competition held in the mid-1980s for a municipal government center for Phoenix, Arizona and is arranged in three subgroups.

Arrangement

This collection is comprised of 8 boxes and 31 oversize folders and items divided into three subgroups:

  1. Subgroup 1: Planning Stage
  2. Subgroup 2: Design Competition Stage
  3. Subgroup 3: Post-Competition Stage

Provenance

The materials in this collection were donated by Dr. Roger Schluntz of the ASU College of Architecture and Environmental Design in April 1992; by Charles Hill from the ASU Office of the President in 1994; and by The Herberger College of the Arts in 2003.

Title
Phoenix Municipal Government Center Design Competition Collection
Status
Completed
Author
Processed by Paul G. Hubbard and Dennis D. Madden in August 1994 and by Harold Housley in June 2016.
Date
2017
Description rules
Describing Archives: A Content Standard
Language of description
English
Script of description
Latin
Language of description note
Finding guide encoded in English.

Repository details

Part of the Design and the Arts Special Collections Repository

Contact

Arizona State University
P.O. Box 871705
Tempe AZ 85287-1705 United States
480-965-6370