Skip to main content

John S. McCain III Papers

 Collection
Identifier: MSS-409

Scope and Content Note

Record Group 1: U.S. House Files

Series I: Constituent Services (1983-1986) houses mail, phone intake sheets, casework, and other records documenting the McCain office’s constituent service work. Constituent service refers to a wide array of non-legislative activities undertaken by Members of Congress or their staff. This work is widely considered to be a representational responsibility. This series has been divided into two sub-series.

Sub-Series A: Constituent Correspondence houses mail sent to McCain’s office by constituents during the 98th and 99th Congresses. These letters usually include the author’s opinions on legislation and petitions or are personal notes to McCain. This sub-series is organized chronologically and then by the subject. Subjects were assigned by the processing archivists and include Budget and Government Spending, Civil and Constitutional Rights, Environment, Foreign Affairs, Healthcare, Military and Veterans, Post Office and Civil Service, Social Security, Taxes, and Telecommunications. Phone call intake sheets, newspaper clippings, and cards attached to incoming correspondence are also present. All materials in this series are restricted until 50 years after their date of creation.

Sub-Series B: Constituent Casework houses files documenting the McCain office’s work with individual constituents who requested their assistance with a grievance with a federal agency or with the federal government. Examples include issues relating to immigration, Social Security benefits, the military, the Veterans’ Administration, and the Internal Revenue Service. These files include summary casework sheets, correspondence with constituents and government agencies, and other records relating to the case in question. All materials in this sub-series are restricted until 75 years after their date of creation.

Series II: Correspondence (1982-1986) houses written communications between McCain’s office and other entities. Sub-Series A: Government Officials (1982-1986) houses correspondence with representatives of federal, state, local, tribal, and foreign governments. These correspondents include Senators, Representatives, the Senate Sergeant at Arms, the Library of Congress, the National Republican Congressional Committee, and the Tohono O’odham Nation (which was then using the name Papago Tribe of Arizona). Correspondence with congresspeople from Arizona and Speaker of the House Thomas P. O’Neill are foldered separately. Many of these items were separated from Series I, Sub-Series A: Constituent Correspondence; a smaller number were removed from Series II, Sub-Series B: General Correspondence.

Sub-Series B: General Correspondence (1983-1986) houses communications not classified as constituent correspondence or correspondence with government officials. Alphabetical Blues and Greens, Alphabetical Whites, Alphabetical Yellows, and Chronological Pinks reflect the McCain office’s organizational schema and have been maintained in the order in which they were received. The remaining materials in this sub-series were either unlabeled, unfoldered, or removed from Series I, Sub-Series A: Constituent Correspondence. These materials have been arranged in chronological order.

Sub-Series C: Acknowledgements (1983-1986) houses materials that McCain’s office stored in folders labeled as Thank-yous, Congratulations, and similar. They include such correspondence as government officials thanking McCain for his votes on various pieces of legislation. Similar items are present in both Sub-Series A and Sub-Series B but were not found as part of a larger group of items.

Series III: Subject Files (1974-1989) house meeting notes, internal communications, memoranda, working drafts of bills, and reference materials like reports and newspaper clippings documenting legislative and national issues, state issues, and Phoenix community organizations. Sub-Series A: Legislative and National Issue Files (1974-1989) includes Aging, Energy and Commerce, Foreign Affairs, Social Security, and Veterans Affairs. Sub-Series B: Arizona Project Files (1983-1986) houses materials having to do with the Arizona Project. Sub-Series C: Arizona Community Organizations (1982-1986) represents organizations supporting children’s services, food banks and other food assistance programs, and environmental causes.

Series IV: Administrative Files (1981-1986) contain materials documenting the McCain office’s internal operations. Sub-Series A: Speeches, Statements, and Voting Records (1983-1986) contains draft and final versions of prepared remarks delivered before Congress and to non-governmental entities, entries for the Congressional Record, and copies of McCain’s voting record. Most of these remarks were delivered by John McCain in his capacity as a Representative, but some remarks delivered by Cindy McCain are also included. Sub-Series B: Schedules (1982-1986) consists primarily of McCain’s monthly and daily schedules. Schedules documenting his public appearances and his extension office schedules are also present. Sub-Series C: Office Administration (1981-1986) documents the internal operations of McCain’s office in Washington, D.C. as well as his district offices in Mesa and Tempe. Most of these items show the McCain office’s intern program, document standard office procedures, or are documents like guestbooks, office leases, and Town Hall meeting attendance. Sub-Series D: Press (1982-1986) includes press releases issued by McCain’s office as well as newsclippings discussing McCain or other contemporary figures and issues of interest.

Sub-Series E: Events (1984-1986) consists primarily of materials documenting McCain’s participation in the Republican Recognition Dinners held in 1984, 1985, and 1986. The Congressman Ed Zschau High Technology Dinner (1984), a National Park Service Colorado River patrol trip (1985), and a Captain's Club membership party (1986 February) are also represented.

Record Group 2: U.S. Senate Files

Series I: Constituent Services has been divided into two sub-series. Sub-Series A: Constituent Correspondence (1987-2007) consists of mail received by Senator McCain’s office from members of the public, usually expressing their opinions on legislation or conveying personal messages to the Senator. In addition to letters and printed emails, these records include phone call intake sheets and any news clippings, drawings, and photographs that were attached to correspondence. Interspersed personal and professional correspondence between Senator McCain and other Members of Congress or VIPs were not removed; however, the majority of McCain’s correspondence with government officials and dignitaries can be found in Series II: Correspondence.

Sub-Sub-Series 1: Issue Mail (1987-2007) is arranged alphabetically by subject and then chronologically within each category. The processing team randomly sampled this mail with the goal of reducing its overall volume by two-thirds. This correspondence includes samples of casework, or the services that Members of Congress provide to constituents seeking assistance. Constituent casework and issue mail (correspondence and casework) are restricted for 75 years from the date of creation.

Sub-Sub-Series 2: Letter Templates and Reports (1987-1994), arranged chronologically, includes form letter templates and reports generated from the office’s constituent correspondence management system (CMS) reflecting the volume of mail received. It is often organized by topic and subtopic, both of which were assigned by the McCain office. This data does not include personally identifiable information about constituents and is therefore not restricted.

Sub-Series B: Grants (1991-2001) consists of files arranged alphabetically by the name of the grantseeker and is typically composed of correspondence, pamphlets, and applications. Those seeking federal grants often approach Member offices for information, referrals, and assistance.

Series II: Correspondence (1973-2018 (bulk 1987-2018)) consists of written communications between Senator McCain’s office and various government officials and dignitaries. Sub-Series A: Government Affairs (1986-2018) houses written communications sent and received by the Senator’s office in the regular course of business and typically includes opinions on upcoming legislation or federal appointments.

Sub-Series B: Thank You Letters (1984-2016), arranged chronologically, includes written letters of appreciation to and from the Senator’s office. Most of the incoming correspondence pertains to issues, while the outgoing correspondence consists of acknowledgments. Sub-Series C: Invitations and Events (1973-2003), arranged chronologically, contains invitations to events that Senator McCain or his staff accepted and attended. Sub-Series D: Personal (1994-2018), arranged chronologically, consists primarily of birthday greetings, well wishes, and condolences regarding Senator McCain’s illness and death.

Series III: Legislative Files (1907-2018 (bulk 1980-2018)) reflects the role of McCain’s office in the legislative process and consists of documents used or created by Senator McCain and his staff in reference to specific issues and pieces of legislation.

Sub-Series A: Issue Files (1907-2018 (bulk 1980-2018)) consists of subject files maintained by Senator McCain’s Washington, D.C. office staff. The files are arranged alphabetically by subject and typically include the staff’s meeting notes, internal communications, memoranda, working drafts of bills, and collected reference material such as reports and news clippings. In an effort to preserve the context in which the files were originally created, the processing team recorded the name of the staffer and/or committee associated with each file in an item-level note.

Sub-Series B: Briefing Books (1987-2007) is made up of briefing books, or documentation provided to a decisionmaker summarizing an issue, usually in support of policy findings or recommendations. Most of the briefing books were prepared for Senator McCain in advance of committee hearings. Arranged chronologically, the briefing books typically include memoranda, summaries, statements, witness lists, questions, testimonies, and news clippings.

Sub-Series C: Bill Files (1986-2018), arranged chronologically, consists of working drafts of bills and amendments that Senator McCain sponsored, co-sponsored, or supported, often with his accompanying floor statement. In addition to the draft documents, the files may include a variety of supporting documentation like notes, action plans, research materials on subjects raised in the bills and amendments, memos between staff, stakeholder names and background information, and incoming correspondence expressing support for or opposition to the proposed legislation.

Sub-Series D: Committee Files (1978-2013 (bulk 1985-2013) documents Senator McCain’s activities in the capacity of his committee assignments. The original records for Senate committees are preserved by the Archives of the U.S. Senate; as such, the files in this subseries largely consist of copies of correspondence, memoranda, and briefing materials. The files are arranged chronologically within each sub-sub-series, which are listed in alphabetical order by the name of the committee. Committees included are Appropriations; Armed Services; Commerce, Science and Transportation; Ethics; Foreign Relations; Health, Education, Labor & Pensions; Indian Affairs; and POW/MIA Affairs.

Sub-Series E: State/District Member Interest Files (1986-2008) comprises subject files maintained by the staff of Senator McCain’s Arizona offices. Arranged alphabetically by subject, the files include correspondence, memoranda, notes, reference materials, and news clippings.

Sub-Series F: Political Files (1985-1989, 2004-2005) represents a small subset of files maintained by Senator McCain’s staff pertaining to surveys, interest groups, and Republican Party campaign activities.

Series IV: Administrative Files (1968-2018 (bulk 1987-2018)) reflects the internal functions of McCain’s Senate office. Sub-Series A: Press Files (1968-2014 (bulk 1987-2014)) includes publicity material maintained by Senator McCain’s office and is divided into three sub-subseries: Press Releases (arranged chronologically), Subject Files (arranged alphabetically by subject), and Clippings (arranged chronologically). The files contain press releases and statements produced by Senator McCain’s office, as well as magazines and news clippings gathered by the office. The processing team deselected news clippings from prominent national outlets in order to focus on local Arizona news.

Sub-Series B: Speech Files (1984-2017) contains drafts and copies of prepared remarks that Senator McCain delivered. It is divided into two Sub-Sub-Series, Speeches and Addresses and Statements. Each sub-sub-series is arranged chronologically.

Sub-Series C: Schedules (1983-2018 (bulk 1987-2018)) consists of itineraries and planners created by Senator McCain’s offices in Washington D.C., Mesa, and Phoenix from 1986 to 2018. In addition to routine itineraries and planners, the scheduling records also include travel information, invitations, event and meeting details, and participant information. The subseries is further divided into five sub-subseries based on the period of the planner or the nature of the travel.

Sub-Series D: Donations (1987-2017), arranged alphabetically by type, consists of donation and contribution receipts, lists of contributors, and honoraria and gift correspondence. Receipts include outgoing notices from Senator McCain’s offices and incoming letters from organizations.

Record Group 3: Campaign Records

This record group houses opposition research, polls and surveys conducted by the campaign and other entities, speeches, newspaper clippings, letters to the editor, press releases, correspondence, endorsements, operational files, administrative files, and other materials documenting McCain’s political campaigns between 1968 and 2016. Administrative files generally include materials documenting the campaign’s internal processes and include scheduling and invitations, financial records, and other documentation needed to support the campaign’s management. Operational files usually comprise materials relating to the core mandate of the campaign and reflect activities unique to political campaigns. These materials include campaign strategy and activities intended to attract voters and ensure the candidate’s presence on the ballot. Most of the content in this series documents McCain’s campaign for the 2000 Republican Party Presidential nomination and 2008 presidential campaign.

Series I: House of Representatives Campaigns (1979-1985) consists primarily of materials documenting McCain’s election to the House of Representatives in 1982. Other materials include McCain’s 1984 re-election campaign. Series II: Senate Campaigns (1968-2016) documents McCain’s successful bid for the United States Senate in 1986 and his re-election campaigns in 1992, 1998, 2004, 2010, and 2016.

Series III: Republican Presidential Primary Campaign (1977-2002) documents McCain’s unsuccessful campaign for the Republican Party’s Presidential nomination in 2000. Series IV: Presidential Campaign (1992-2009) details McCain’s 2008 campaign for the presidency of the United States. Both of these series house speeches, position statements, research files, polling data, schedules, operational files, administrative files, correspondence, and endorsements. Series IV also includes direct mail and other promotional materials, financial records, and records showing planning and preparation for debates and post-debate analysis.

Series IV: Political Activity (1986-2011) houses records showing McCain’s political activities during years in which he was not up for election or re-election. These files include work with political action committees, endorsements, speeches, schedules, and correspondence regarding McCain’s stumping for other candidates. These candidates include Phil Gramm, Matt Salmon, and Pete Wilson.

Detailed description of Record Group 4: Digital Records and Record Group 5: Audio/Visual Materials will be added when they become available for research.

Record Group 6: Memorabilia and Ephemera has been divided into three series. Series I: United States House of Representatives (1982-1985) and Series II: United States Senate (1987-2009) are composed of certificates of appreciation (usually issued by groups that McCain spoke to), awards, honorary doctorate degrees, and other similar materials. Series III: Campaign Records (circa 1994-2008) consists of posters, yard signs, bumper stickers, hats, t-shirts, banners, buttons, and other promotional materials produced during McCain’s congressional and presidential campaigns. The bulk of these materials are housed in Sub-Series C: Presidential Campaign (2008). Other sub-series include Sub-Series A: Senate Campaigns (circa 1994-2004), Sub-Series B: Republican Presidential Primary Campaign (2000), Sub-Series D: Political Activity (circa 2004), and Sub-Series E: Unidentified McCain Campaigns.

Record Group 7: Photographs (1969-2008) is composed of physical photographs depicting McCain after his release from prison in Vietnam; McCain with other Congresspeople; McCain participating in trips to Germany, Egypt, Asia, and Jerusalem; McCain at events like speeches, his Congressional swearing-in, and the Fiesta Bowl Parade; and visitors to the McCain offices. Several members of the McCain family, including Admiral John McCain Jr., Cindy McCain, and Jack McCain, are also shown. The majority of the photographs in this collection, including digital surrogates of several photographs in this record group, are housed in Record Group 4: Digital Records and depict McCain’s 2008 Presidential campaign.

A Note on McCain's Interaction with Senate Office Staff

During McCain’s Senate service the personal offices of United States Senators were run in accordance with the discretion of the given Senator and his or her key staff members: chiefs of staff (also called administrative assistants), legislative directors, schedulers, and office managers. The nature of the daily interaction between Senator and staff still varies markedly from one office to the next.

These notes are provided to help researchers using Senator McCain's Senate office papers to understand what they are likely to find (or not find) given Senator McCain's work habits. There are three key points to note. First, Senator McCain produced very little written material from his own hand, either in analog or digital form. His instructions to staffers were ordinarily verbal or took the form of marginal comments on the draft documents submitted to him. Even hand-written notes to friends and dignitaries are relatively scarce, and most that survive will be found only in the papers of the recipients. He relied heavily upon his memory and experience to keep his thoughts in order and did not dictate memoranda of his own for his files. Accordingly, the best records we possess that shed light on his thinking are the finished work products edited by his staffers: legislative language, speeches, op-eds, floor statements, social media postings, and signed versions of letters. McCain attended very closely to this output and often required multiple revisions before he was fully satisfied. Notes taken by staff members in their interactions with the Senator are also valuable where these survive. To a great extent, the care taken by particular staff members is the best predictor of whether the record will be fat or thin, clear or cryptic. Similarly, McCain seldom asked staff to provide a record of his meetings. Where such notes are found in the Senate papers, they were typically written by legislative assistants who wanted to retain their own account of the interaction. Senator McCain did not generate any email of his own, whether personal or official, and his social media postings - including Tweets - were drafted by staff and reviewed by the Senator like the rest of the office's output. In later years McCain sent text messages to close friends (none were retained) but his preferred means of contact was always to speak on the telephone. He filled unscheduled time with spontaneous phone calls to friends and associates all over the world. In most cases, no records of these conversations exist other than in the Senator's published reminiscences.

Second, Senator McCain's interaction with staff members was direct and fluid. When he had no meetings underway, his office door was generally open and legislative assistants who had worked for him to review simply knocked and asked to speak with him. Formal deliberation of major decisions rarely involved cognizant legislative staff members, however, largely because Senator McCain, after long years on the Hill, knew what he thought and retained relevant detail. Moreover, he could rely upon long-serving senior staffers and campaign staff - active or former - for crucial advice. When Senator McCain had business with another member of either party, he often took these meetings in the Capitol itself and frequently did so alone. Generally, there is no record of such conversations. If other Senators visited him in his office, McCain's staff members might attend if the other Senators also had staff in tow. Otherwise, these meetings, too, were confined to the members themselves.

Travel was closely connected with his sense that the Senate was a deliberative body with a duty to remain closely informed about the world and the impact of American policy. The staff members who organized his travel - generally his foreign policy or national security legislative assistants - were among his most trusted and experienced aides. Records generated by travel may include background briefing materials, itineraries, dramatis personae of meetings, etc. Other Senate offices frequently participated, and Senator McCain made a special effort to introduce junior Senate colleagues to Senate travel by inviting them along on Congressional delegations. The records of other Senate offices may therefore be of interest.

Dates

  • Creation: 1907-2018
  • Creation: Majority of material found within 1965-2018

Creator

Language of Materials

Material in English

Access Restrictions

Portions of the collection are restricted as follows:

  1. Constituent correspondence is restricted for 50 years from the date of creation.
  2. Constituent casework and "issue mail" (correspondence and casework) are restricted for 75 years from the date of creation.
  3. House Committee records are closed for 30 years from the date of creation; Senate Committee records are closed for 20 years from the date of creation.
  4. Records regarding national security, investigations, and the privacy of living individuals are closed for 50 years from the date of creation.

Materials in this collection can only be viewed by appointment in the Wurzburger Reading Room at Hayden Library (rm. 138). Patrons will be asked to sign an end user agreement (https://libguides.asu.edu/arizonacollection) before access is granted. Digitization is not available for this collection, but patrons may use personal cameras or phone cameras without flash to capture images of materials. Personal scanning equipment is not permitted. We are currently limiting each patron to 10 boxes per day. Please make an appointment at least five business days prior to your visit by contacting Ask an Archivist or call (480) 965-4932 for more information. Check the ASU Library Hours page for current availability.

All media inquiries about this collection will go through ASU Media Relations: https://newsroom.asu.edu/contact

Copyright

The Arizona Board of Regents retains copyright to this collection for and on behalf of Distinctive Collections, Arizona State University Library. Requests for permissions to publish, display, or redistribute information from this collection must be submitted via our online application.

Biographical Note

John Sidney McCain III (1936–2018) was born to John Sidney McCain, Jr. (1911–1981) and Roberta (Wright) McCain (1912–2020) in the Panama Canal Zone on August 29, 1936. He was the second of three children and the scion of a prominent American naval family. His grandfather, Admiral John S. McCain, Sr., commanded a carrier task force during the Second World War and was awarded the Navy Cross for heroism. McCain's father also achieved four-star rank and eventually served as the U.S. Commander-in-Chief in the Pacific during the height of the Vietnam War. McCain graduated from Episcopal High School in Alexandria, Virginia in 1954. Like his father and grandfather, he attended the United States Naval Academy, graduating in 1958. McCain entered flight school at Naval Air Basic Training Command at Pensacola immediately after graduation and began his career as a naval aviator flying ground attack aircraft in 1960.

McCain's combat duty began in July 1967 as part of Operation Rolling Thunder over North Vietnam. On October 26, 1967, during his 23rd bombing mission over Hanoi, Lieutenant Commander McCain joined a 20-plane mission to bomb a power plant in the capital city and was shot down. McCain suffered serious injury while ejecting from his stricken aircraft and after landing in a lake in central Hanoi was stabbed and beaten. After cursory medical treatment he was taken to the Hoa Lo Prison, nicknamed the Hanoi Hilton. In December 1967, McCain was transferred to a different camp on the outskirts of Hanoi. After refusing to accept parole in advance of other prisoners, he was put in solitary confinement in March 1968, where he remained for two years. His captors began torturing him in August 1968, and McCain eventually made an anti-American propaganda confession. He was subsequently abused for refusing to sign additional statements.

Under the ceasefire agreement reached by the United States and North Vietnam on January 27, 1973, one hundred and eight American prisoners of war—including McCain—were released on March 14, 1973. He received numerous awards for his service, including the Silver Star, Legion of Merit, Purple Heart, and Distinguished Flying Cross. After undergoing treatment for his injuries, McCain had his flight status reinstated in 1974 and became the commanding officer of a training squadron in Florida. Thereafter he became the Navy's liaison to the U.S. Senate beginning in 1977. In this role McCain traveled extensively with congressional delegations and established ties with members of the Senate that would subsequently prove important to his career in Congress.

McCain met Carol Shepp while stationed at Pensacola in 1964. They married on July 3, 1965, and McCain adopted her two young sons, Douglas and Andrew. The couple later had a daughter, Sidney, in 1966. In April 1979, McCain met Cindy Lou Hensley at a military reception in Hawaii, and they developed a relationship. In February 1980, Shepp consented to a divorce, which was finalized in April 1980; the two remained on good terms. McCain and Hensley married on May 17, 1980, and had four children: Meghan (1984–), John Sidney IV (1986–), James (1988–), and Bridget (a Bangladeshi child adopted at the age of 3 months in 1991).

In 1981, McCain retired from the Navy at the rank of captain and moved to Phoenix, Arizona with Cindy to begin a career in politics. He was elected to the U.S. House of Representatives in 1983 as Representative from Arizona's 1st district in the 98th and 99th Congresses, serving on the House Education and Labor, House Foreign Affairs, and House Interior and Insular Affairs Committees. McCain was elected to the U.S. Senate in 1987, succeeding conservative icon Barry Goldwater, and served Arizona for over 30 years. He earned a reputation as a maverick Republican, working extensively to end pork barrel spending and enact campaign finance reform.

McCain’s policy legacy is complex. In foreign affairs, he favored a strong military posture, assertive American leadership, democracy promotion, and human rights. His historical Senate voting record is conservative, earning an 80.9 percent lifetime rating from the American Conservative Union through 2017. However, in the early 2000s, he broke publicly with President George W. Bush on issues such as campaign finance, tax cuts, HMO reform, climate change, and gun control. Most notably, perhaps, McCain resolutely opposed the Bush administration concerning the torture and abuse of detainees held in American custody in the Global War on Terror. He also sought bipartisan solutions on domestic matters like immigration and healthcare alongside the Obama Administration. In 2013, McCain was censured by the Arizona Republican Party for a liberal voting record. Some liberal critics, however, question McCain's reputation for independence. They cite his strong support for the 2003 invasion of Iraq, his selection of Governor Sarah Palin as his 2008 running mate, and his vote for the 2017 Republican tax reform bill as evidence he was not a bipartisan outlier.

During his Senate tenure, he served on the Committee on Armed Services (Chairman); Commerce Committee (twice Chairman); Committee on Homeland Security and Governmental Affairs; Permanent Subcommittee on Investigations, Subcommittee on Financial and Contracting Oversight; Committee on Indian Affairs (twice Chairman); Select Committee on POW / MIA Affairs; and Select Committee on Intelligence (ex-officio). Additional service included participation in the International Conservation Caucus; Senate Diabetes Caucus; Senate National Security Caucus (Co-Chair); Sportsmen's Caucus; Senate Wilderness and Public Lands Caucus; Senate Ukraine Caucus; and the Republican Main Street Partnership. McCain also served for many years as the chairman of the International Republic Institute, a federally funded NGO dedicated to the promotion of free and fair elections world-wide and to the training of pro-democratic parties. McCain made an unsuccessful bid for the Republican Party's presidential nomination in 2000 and ran as the Republican candidate for president against Barack Obama in 2008. Obama prevailed against the background of public war weariness and the onset of the global financial crisis. During the 2016 Republican primaries and while running for a sixth Senate term, McCain pledged to support the party nominee, including Donald Trump. In October 2016, he withdrew support for Trump, citing Trump's demeaning comments about women. McCain's relationship with the Trump administration was strained by McCain's decisive vote against the repeal of the Affordable Care Act. McCain was particularly outspoken in his criticism of President Trump's handling of U.S.-Russia relations.

In July 2017 McCain was diagnosed with glioblastoma. McCain died at home in Cornville, Arizona, on August 25, 2018. Following services in Arizona, he lay in state at the Capitol Rotunda before his interment in the United States Naval Academy Cemetery in Annapolis, Maryland, on September 2, 2018.

Highlights of McCain's Political Career

The Keating Five Scandal and Campaign Finance Reform

Charles Keating was a leading figure in Arizona’s business community when John McCain entered politics. He was an important networker and fund-raiser on McCain’s behalf during his two terms in the House and during his bid to succeed Barry Goldwater in the Senate in 1986. The relationship, however, compromised McCain’s image when, in 1989, it became public that Keating had asked five prominent Senators, including McCain, to protect Keating’s failing savings and loan business from federal regulators. Although the Senate Ethics Committee found in 1991 that McCain had not acted improperly on Keating’s behalf, favors that he had accepted from Keating had come to light during the scandal, some of which McCain had failed to disclose as the law required. This incident led McCain to make campaign finance reform a signature issue in the years leading up to his unsuccessful bid, in 2000, for the Republican presidential nomination. McCain and his congressional allies succeeded in passing the Bipartisan Campaign Reform Act (BCRA) in 2002. Among other provisions, the act had sought to curtail the largely unregulated flow of so-called soft money into accounts controlled by party leaders. Despite passage, the Republican leadership’s opposition to the bill’s provisions gained momentum. In the years that followed, a series of Supreme Court decisions, culminating in Citizens United v. The Federal Elections Commission (2010), severely undermined the BCRA. While McCain continued to believe that further campaign finance reform was necessary to protect the integrity of American elections, he took only limited action for the remainder of his Senate career.

Normalization of Relations with Vietnam

Following the Communist victory in Vietnam in 1975, the U.S. government had severed diplomatic relations with the unified country and imposed an economic embargo. As a generally hawkish Republican, decorated Vietnam veteran, and former POW, John McCain was uniquely positioned to affect American policy towards Vietnam. Together with his fellow veteran Senator John Kerry of Massachusetts, McCain, as a member of the Senate Select Committee on POW / MIA Affairs, consulted with the Vietnamese government to address outstanding questions concerning the status of Americans still missing in Vietnam. Convinced that Vietnam was acting in good faith on the MIA issue, McCain and Kerry appeared beside President Bill Clinton at the national Vietnam War Memorial as the president called for an end to the economic embargo (1993). McCain’s stance in favor of normalization and his partnership with Kerry often put him at odds with conservative voters and veterans’ groups. The following year, McCain nonetheless co-sponsored with Kerry a Senate resolution urging repeal of the embargo. Thanks chiefly to McCain’s lobbying, the resolution passed with twenty Republican votes. The embargo ended in 1994, and normal diplomatic relations resumed in 1995.

The 2000 Presidential Race

McCain’s first bid for the presidency was a noteworthy chapter in his lifetime in public service. After his unexpected insurgent victory in New Hampshire, the contest came down to the South Carolina primary on 19 February. Facing both a more conservative Republican electorate and bare-knuckle political tactics from the campaign of Texas Governor George W. Bush, McCain was solidly beaten despite Bush’s inexperience of federal government and world affairs. McCain was unhappy with some of the steps he had taken to mollify conservative South Carolinians, including his refusal to denounce the display of the Confederate Flag at the South Carolina Statehouse, for which he apologized soon after the primary. Nonetheless, after the defeat in South Carolina, the necessity of making peace with the conservative wing of his party was clear to McCain. Some commentators argue that this helps to explain the change of tone and tactics he displayed eight years later in his successful bid for the GOP nomination.

The 9-11 Wars: Iraq and Afghanistan

McCain briefly considered a primary challenge to George Bush in 2004 but the terror attacks of 9-11 foreclosed this possibility. McCain fully supported the administration’s intervention in Afghanistan. In keeping with his own calls for regime change before 9-11, he also supported the widening of the Global War on Terror to Iraq in 2003. McCain advocated consistently for the democratization of both countries and saw the struggle with the Taliban, al Qaeda and other Islamic insurgent groups as a critical test of American resolve. When the American occupation in Iraq faltered, McCain pressed the Bush administration to change military tactics and implement a temporary surge in American troop strength to quell the revolt. Some commentators have argued that McCain’s support for the surge was a severe political handicap in his presidential campaign of 2008. During both conflicts, McCain traveled frequently to the theater of war, consulting with military leadership, American diplomats, and Afghan and Iraqi politicians and officials. Towards the end of his life, McCain expressed retrospective doubts about the wisdom of the Iraq war but argued that an American presence in Afghanistan would be essential for the foreseeable future.

Human Rights, Democracy Promotion, and McCain’s Opposition to Torture

Throughout his career, John McCain took an active interest in the promotion of human rights worldwide. This reflected his confidence in the universality of such rights, which was central to his understanding of the American role in global affairs. McCain met with a wide range of dissidents and activists and pressed for the release of political prisoners in countries such as Myanmar, Russia, Belarus, and Iran. This commitment dovetailed with his extensive efforts to foster the spread of democratic regimes throughout the world, which included for many years his chairmanship of the International Republican Institute. McCain’s support of human rights also led him to criticize American policy. In 2004, following revelations of the torture and humiliation of prisoners detained in the Global war on Terror, McCain authored and led passage of the Detainee Treatment Act of 2005, which prohibited the torture of prisoners held by the U.S. military. In 2015, McCain and California Senator Diane Feinstein led passage of the McCain-Feinstein amendment which extended this protection to prisoners held by the CIA. McCain vocally supported pro-democratic uprisings during the co-called Arab Spring which began in 2010. He fought unsuccessfully to secure active American support for the revolt in Syria from 2011 onward. In 2014, McCain traveled to Kyiv to demonstrate his commitment to Ukrainian independence during the so-called Maidan Revolution. This uprising led to the ouster of a pro-Russian government under Viktor Janukovich and triggered the Russian take-over of Ukraine and a Russian insurgency in the Donetsk and Luhansk districts of eastern Ukraine.

Oversight: the Boeing Tanker Scandal and Abramoff Scandal

Throughout his career, John McCain called for vigorous congressional oversight of the federal government. He considered oversight the hallmark of the system of checks and balances provided for by the U.S. Constitution. This was exemplified by his leadership in the investigation of two noteworthy controversies: the Boeing Tanker scandal (2003-2004) and the Jack Abramoff lobbying scandal (2005-2006). In the Boeing scandal, McCain, as a member of the Senate Armed Service Committee, successfully challenged a $23 billion Air Force contract to lease tankers from the aircraft manufacturer. His investigation revealed that a Department of Defense procurement officer, Darleen Druyun, had steered contracts to Boeing in exchange for job offers. Exposure of the affair led to major reform of military contracting. In the Abramoff case, McCain chaired a two-year investigation by the Senate Indian Affairs Committee which exposed extensive fraud, influence peddling, and corruption. Abramoff pled guilty to conspiracy, fraud, and tax evasion. Here also McCain’s investigative efforts led to legislation with the passage of the Honest Leadership and Open Government Act of 2007, though McCain himself opposed final passage of the bill for failing to eliminate earmarks.

The Commerce Committee

Though best known for his leadership in international affairs and national security policy, John McCain was an active committee chairman during his two terms at the helm of the Senate Commerce Committee (1997-2001 and 2003-2005). In keeping with his classical liberal, free-market convictions, McCain pressed consistently for deregulation, government transparency, and market-oriented reforms. He vocally opposed pork-barrel spending. He took a particular interest in the deregulation of the telecommunications and airline industries and aggressively promoted greater freedom of trade.

The 2008 Presidential Race

John McCain’s 2008 campaign witnessed a series of dramatic ups-and-downs. The auspices for a Republican candidate were not favorable given widespread war weariness and the excitement generated by the rivalry between Democratic Senator Hillary Clinton of New York and Illinois Senator Barack Obama. Though he was initially regarded as the favorite for the GOP nomination, McCain's campaign nearly collapsed in the fall of 2007. He rallied, however, to win the New Hampshire and South Carolina primaries and thereafter consolidated Republican support. Privately, McCain entertained hopes of selecting his friend Senator Joseph Lieberman of Connecticut as his running mate across party lines. He was persuaded, however, that this would split the Republican party and instead chose Alaska Governor Sarah Palin. Though she was popular with the party base, Palin's inexperience and thin knowledge of global affairs soon began to tell, making it harder for McCain to pick up the votes of undecided moderates. Moreover, Barack Obama's victory in the Democratic primary gave the Democratic ticket historic momentum, and the onset of the global financial crisis tended to weaken public confidence in Republican leadership. McCain was soundly defeated, losing the popular vote by more than seven percentage points and the electoral college by 192 votes.

Native American Issues

McCain was a leading legislator on Native American affairs, serving twice as the Chairman of the Senate Committee on Indian Affairs. He was the author and sponsor of several bills to strengthen tribal self-governance. These included the Indian Gaming Regulatory Act of 1988, which formally authorized tribal gaming - a nearly revolutionary, revitalizing source of revenue for many tribes. In 1994, McCain also led the passage of the Indian Self-Determination Contract Reform Amendment and the Tribal Self-Governance Act, which allowed tribes to assume responsibility for many programs previously overseen by the Bureau of Indian Affairs. McCain championed stronger protections to prevent child abuse in Native American communities, sought to extend AMBER alert coverage to Indian reservations, and to improve housing, health care, and education. He played a pivotal role in negotiating and enacting several Arizona tribal water settlement bills and sponsored the Native American Languages Act, which encouraged programs to preserve indigenous dialects. As noted above, he also investigated abusive lobbying practices towards Native Americans in the Abramoff scandal.

Immigration

Throughout his legislative career, McCain pursued bipartisan federal immigration reform. The highpoint of these unsuccessful efforts was a 2005 bill co-authored by Democratic Senator Edward Kennedy of Massachusetts and entitled the Secure America and Orderly Immigration Act. The key provisions included a path to legal status for undocumented immigrants, a reformed guest worker program, and enhanced border security. The bill formed the basis for further attempts at reform in 2006, 2007 and 2013 (the so-called Gang of Eight bill), all of which McCain actively supported and all of which ultimately failed. In his reelection campaign of 2010 McCain took a harder line on illegal immigration. He nonetheless remained committed to the goal of broad reform until the end of his life.

Conservation and Environmental Issues

From the outset of his legislative career, John McCain was instrumental in the preservation and environmental protection of Arizona's extensive public lands, particularly the Grand Canyon and the Colorado River basin. This pattern began with his introduction of the National Parks Overflight Act of 1987, which limited aerial tourism of national parks. Over the years, McCain sponsored several successful amendments to improve water conservation in the basin. Later, McCain took an interest in the problem of global warming. In 2003 and 2005, he co-authored with Senator Lieberman the first major Senate bills to propose a cap-and-trade approach to limiting greenhouse gas emissions. Neither became law, but the approach was widely imitated in subsequent (albeit equally unsuccessful) bills.

Full extent

2277 Box(es)

Full extent

1146.53 Linear Feet

Abstract

The John S. McCain Papers house textual, visual, and digital records dating from 1907 to 2018 (bulk dates 1965-2018) that Senator McCain and his staff created and compiled over his three and a half decades of political service as representative from Arizona's 1st District in the United States House of Representatives, as an United States Senator from Arizona, and as a two-time candidate and onetime Republican nominee for President of the United States.

Arrangement

This collection consists of two thousand, two hundred and seventy-seven boxes divided into seven record groups:

  1. Record Group 1: United States House of Representatives
  2. Record Group 2: United States Senate
  3. Record Group 3: Campaign Records
  4. Record Group 4: Digital Records
  5. Record Group 5: Audio/Visual Materials
  6. Record Group 6: Memorabilia and Ephemera
  7. Record Group 7: Photographs

Provenance

John S. McCain by way of the McCain Institute Foundation donated these materials to Arizona State University beginning in 1990 through 2014, with a final donation in 2019.

Processing Note

Given the large volume of unprocessed analog and digital Senate office records, ASU Library ruled out staffing for these materials in-house, choosing instead to partner with an outside vendor.

Upon accession, materials housed in Record Group 1, Series I, Sub-Series A: Constituent Correspondence were variously organized by subject, date, and correspondent. In order to facilitate sampling and researcher access, these materials were arranged by Congressional session and then by subject. Subject terms assigned generally reflect House Congressional Committees dating from the Congresses represented. Personal and professional correspondence discovered during this process was removed to Series II: Correspondence and such items as military academy reference requests, student letters, and requests for flags and signed photographs were deaccessioned in full. After arrangement, weighted sampling was conducted and approximately half of the total contents were deaccessioned.

Materials housed in Record Group 1, Series I, Sub-Series B: Constituent Casework generally lacked organization at the time of accession. Archivists arranged these materials by the relevant government agency and then by the date the case originated with McCain’s office. After arrangement, weighted sampling was conducted and approximately two fifths of the total material was deaccessioned.

Processing is not yet complete for Record Group 4: Digital Records and Record Group 5: Audio/Visual Materials. Descriptions for these portions of the collection will be updated as they are completed.

Title
John S. McCain III Papers
Status
In Progress
Author
Processed by Claudia Willett, Katie Simpson, Zoie Ypsilanti, and Elizabeth Dunham between 2019 and 2025.
Date
July 2019; updated April 2022
Description rules
Describing Archives: A Content Standard
Language of description
English
Script of description
Latin
Language of description note
Finding guide encoded in English.

Repository details

Part of the Greater Arizona Collection Repository

Contact

Arizona State University
P.O. Box 871006
Tempe AZ 85287-1006 United States
(480) 965-4932